When Lori Callahan meets Jack and Brandt at an auto care class they teach, she isn't sure which one of them is hitting on her more. They invite her out for drinks, and she's surprised to learn they're already a couple... but they're looking for someone like her to complete them. Drinks turn into a date, which leads to much more. Jack Rowe and Peter Brandt have been together since high school, and fight like an old married couple. They don't agree on anything, it seems, except sex and how they both feel about Lori. But soon she finds herself caught in between the two. She doesn't want to take sides when her men fight -- she loves them both, and knows they love each other, even if they never say the words out loud. One evening Brandt pushes Jack too far. Will Lori be able to patch things up between them, or will their loving threesome fall apart for good?